Maile has no plans to support municipalities to procure electricity from IPPs

Our residents are once again suffering through another round of load-shedding simply because the State-Owned Entity (SOE) Eskom is just not up to the task of providing a regular supply of electricity to the country.

In addition, it is very worrying that the Gauteng Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (COGTA) has no intention of assisting municipalities in the province to procure electricity from Independent Power Producers (IPPs).

This information was revealed to me in a reply to my written questions tabled in the Gauteng Provincial Legislature (GPL) to the MEC for COGTA, Lebogang Maile. According to the MEC, the department will not be providing any support to municipalities as Section 154 of the Constitution makes provision for municipalities to do this on their own.

However, given the current state of our municipalities especially the local and district municipalities, it would be prudent for MEC Maile, to provide any assistance they may need to procure additional electricity that will at least provide some protection from load shedding.

Procuring electricity from IPPs is of vital importance, especially since the MEC for Economic Development, Parks Tau admitted that around 122 500 jobs have been lost in this province to the continued load-shedding.

The DA is demanding that MEC Maile together with other municipalities follow the lead taken by the City of Johannesburg Mayor, Mpho Phalatse in holding an energy summit. This is crucial if we want our struggling municipalities like Emfuleni and Merafong to become financially more secure as a continued supply of electricity is crucial to keep the wheels of any economy turning.


Focused Intervention and Less Fluff to Stimulate Gauteng job growth

Note to Editors: This address was made in the Gauteng Provincial Legislature during the 2015/16 Annual Budget Debate on the Department of Economic Development Budget Vote


The current rate of unemployment particularly amongst the youth should be the number one focus and concern of everyone who cares about the future of our country. Gauteng is home to the most unemployed and out-of education labour force in the country at a shocking rate of 49.9% according to recent labour force statistics. It has increased year on year by 9% or 282 000 since the previous financial year. This figure is a clear indicator that Gauteng is sitting on a ticking time bomb!

It is also an indictment on an administration that has entities such as the Gauteng Enterprise Propellor (GEP), Gauteng Funding Agency (GFA) and the Gauteng Growth and Development Agency at its disposal to stimulate economic and job growth.

A person with a job is a person with dignity, a person who can hold his or her up head high before their family, a person who can put bread on the table.

We have to work together to break the vicious cycle of low growth, high inflation and high unemployment.

The DA understands this cannot be done by one sector of South Africa on its own: it needs a joint effort from the government, state-owned enterprises, labour, business, educational and research institutions as well as individuals who must all play their part.

Nothing more clearly illustrates the deep divide between the “haves” and the “have-nots” than the contrast between the 15.5 million South Africans who are working as compared to the 3.2 million South Africans who have given up looking for work together with the 5.5 million who are not able to find employment.

The biggest sector of the unemployed is the youth which make up 70% of the total unemployed population in South Africa. According to the Daily Vox this mean there are more jobless young people today than ever before. The reasons for this, amongst others are:  the skills mismatch; the education system; training that occurs in a vacuum; poor networks i.e. not what you know but who you know; government programs that don’t understand the youth; and discouraging the spirit of entrepreneurship.

The budget of the Department of Economic Development has increased by R205 119 000 or 8.25 %.

The main focus of the Department should be to facilitate conditions for increased job creation. This would mean cutting red tape and unnecessary regulations that make it difficult for small businesses to start up and thrive; it would mean encouraging local government structures to make the life of hawkers easier; it would mean setting up special economic zones where some regulations are relaxed; it would mean fast tracking applications for business and liquor licences; it would mean reducing the burden of paying for E-Tolls; it would mean exempting small businesses from onerous labour legislation and it would mean creating markets with better access for small businesses.

All this would lead to increased economic growth.

The proposed budget by the Department of Economic Development for 2015/16 makes little mention of actual job targets.  The official unemployment rate in Gauteng is slightly higher than the national unemployment rate in South Africa. Trade, community and social services (government) and finance are the biggest employers of the province’s work force.

Gauteng is the heart of the financial services sector (business, banking, finance and IT) in the country with many head offices based in the province.  We should take advantage of this employment opportunity, but our education system needs to provide learners with the skills to take up positions in these industries.

Sadly the manufacturing sector in the province is declining mainly due to the lack of reliable water and electricity resources and an inflexible labour system prompting many to take their factories and prospects of employment to our neighbours like Lesotho and Botswana. General Electric one of the US’s great industrial companies has decided to locate its Africa headquarters in Nairobi rather than Sandton.  This move is apparently driven just as much by easy access to a huge market of people as it is by the infrastructure challenges faced in South Africa.

The various entities that are funded by the Department have grand plans but little action or measurable targets. The Gauteng Enterprise Propellor (GEP) is proud to report on having financially supported 643 existing SMMEs, 673 new SMMEs and 95 existing Cooperatives but we have no idea whether these are one man bands or exactly how many people benefitted. The Department claims to have created 4006 direct jobs which comes at a cost of R276 000 per job taking into consideration the annual budget of the Department.  This money could have been far better spent on training young, unemployed residents of Gauteng and giving them the skills to participate in the financial sector. More effort should be made to ensure the sustainability of the SMME sector beyond just incubation and then abandonment.

This could be done by creating greater market access for SMMEs.

The ANC seems to think that it is only through state contracts and procurement by the state that it can grow black businesses and black employment. This is borne out of the announcement that the Gauteng Provincial Government will ensure 30% of its procurement is from small black owned businesses.  This is a fallacy, as businesses dependant on state contracts and tenders are not increasing competition and competing in the market – which in turn lowers the price of goods and services, without stimulating demand and creating jobs.

There are no programmes in place to assist small businesses to have greater market access so to supply goods and services to other businesses and to consumers directly rather than just to the State. MEC Maile keeps speaking about the ‘white monopoly capital’ value chain but doesn’t have any programmes to ensure market access for new entrants. Furthermore, there is no programme around red tape reduction or any assessment of business processes to see where the state is creating bottlenecks and barriers to entry for SMMEs.

A DA led Gauteng Department of Economic Development should do the following;

  • Open a red tape reduction programme and dedicated support centre to assist SMMEs to deal with red tape
  • Use the broadband capacity of the Gauteng Broadband Network to provide every start up business and SMME with (1) a basic website, (2) e-mail and(3) search engine optimisation (so they appear on google searches) as part of a market access programme;
  • Set up a portal with comparative pricing for businesses and consumers to be able to source goods and services from SMMEs as part of a market access programme – this will force them to compete with each other for business and not only for state tenders; and
  • Encourage larger small enterprises to provide goods and services (particularly high value goods and scare skills based services such as ICT) to all SADC countries as opportunities for growth and access to new markets. The department should facilitate where necessary

The Gauteng Enterprise Propeller (GEP) is receiving a marginal increase in budget, from R129 291 000 to R129 838 000. It would make more sense for GEP to absorb, manage and run all of the department’s SMME support programmes, turning it into a one stop shop for small business incubation and support. It has had a difficult history, but under its new CEO has had quite a turnaround (the CEO is a former Standard Bank executive if I remember correctly). However, GEPs continued financing of small businesses is money that could be used elsewhere if part of its mandate was to ensure start-ups are viable and in a position to access capital from the private sector, making GEP a lender of last resort. It makes no sense when many private sector financial institutions have the programmes and capital for start-ups to run identical programmes.

My colleague, Janho Engelbrecht and I last week visited the Gauteng Investment Centre (GIC) in Sandton. This place and the friendly, informative people who work there actually changed my perception of government entities forever. My main criticism of the GIC has always been why is it in Sandton?

Yes I understand the rationale that it is close to the Gautrain and a short train ride from O R Tambo for foreign investors. This sets the bar high for all such facilities in your Department and we should try and mirror this set up all over Gauteng.

I got the feeling that the people who work in the GIC are passionate about what they do and really want to help. How refreshing!

My suggestion would be that we transform all GEP offices throughout the Province into similar type operations. Obviously not as luxurious but bright, modern and with a “we aim to please” attitude. The one stop shop concept of having Home Affairs, VSP and SARS on the same premises to speed up visa applications and tax clearance is a winner and grouping similar type services in offices such as GEP would make the whole process of doing business in Gauteng so much easier. This would lead to more investment and greater employment and the opportunity of a more prosperous life for all.


Madam Speaker,

South African democracy has now come of age. We stood in long queues for the first time in 1994, full of hopes and dreams of a South Africa we can all proudly call our home. A place where opportunities wouldn’t be a pipe-dream, but a reality that could be reached when one applies themselves.

Amartya Sen in his Book, “Development as Freedom” persuasively argues that freedom is at once the ultimate goal of social and economic arrangements and the most efficient means of realizing general welfare.

Madam speaker, even though our people today have a right to vote, which is something hard won, this hasn’t really freed them. Most in South Africa may not be technically speaking “slaves”, they are denied elementary freedom and remain imprisoned in one way or another by economic poverty, social deprivation, political tyranny or cultural authoritarianism. My colleagues have or will talk on the other contributes. I will today focus on the Economic aspect of the equation.

Events taking place in our country of late demonstrate the growing discontent amongst the unemployed, especially black youth who mainly lives in terrible conditions, feel that, after 21 years of freedom, nothing has changed for them. It’s true. If anything, things have become worse for them. Unemployment is soaring. Food prices are increasing, inflation is sky-high. And crime just keeps getting worse.

The question is then asked “What will it take to realize economic freedom in our lifetime?”

The way we answer this question, will decide the destiny of our country, good or bad. This requires open minds, honesty and intellectual curiosity. No one who cares about South Africa can shy away from it.

People who feel like equals tend to behave like equals. This is why equality of opportunity is the best way to achieve reconciliation and the total freedom we so wish for.

The truth is that the majority of South Africa’s people in 2015 have a legitimate claim to economic redress. Economic inequality is wider than it was in 1994. If we do not redress this, reconciliation – how we relate to one another – is put at risk.

It flows from this that economic freedom, which we precisely define as equality of access to economic opportunity, will only be attained with large scale growth and job creation.

Some people like to talk about “redistribution” as if it is an instant cure for our society’s ills. We saw some organizing jobless youth to  march to the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE), his pretext being that if JSE listed companies “gave” their profits to jobless young people, this would provide economic freedom. Those are the ones who use populist rhetoric about “expropriation without compensation” and “mine nationalisation”. What this group failed to comprehend is that without growth, redress and reconciliation will be consigned to oblivion. We would just be slicing up a shrinking pie.

The solution cannot be to make the rich poorer. It must be to make the rules of the game fairer, and to extend opportunities for those who cannot access them today, this madam speaker, will lead to the true economic freedom which we will see in our lifetime.

The push should therefore should be to create jobs by building many new job creators. The DA’s Growth and Jobs Plan says that we cannot fix South Africa’s economy where it is broken until we create the wealth to invest in education and health.

To build this society requires changes to our economy that will challenge the status quo. We will need to break down the monopolies that keep the cost of living high.

We need to promote greater competition in the economy so that the cost of things like food and clothing comes down.

Building this society requires breaking down the high costs and bureaucratic red tape facing strangling would-be-entrepreneurs and small businesses. And it will mean making it easier for people to access credit so that they can grow and prosper.

Most new jobs in the world today are created by small businesses and innovative companies. This is also how we will dramatically cut youth unemployment.

There is much more that needs to be done to build an inclusive economy. Our Jobs plan say:

We want to distribute shares in the State Owned Enterprises (SOEs) and release ‘dead capital’ by putting financial assets into the hands of poor South Africans.

Hundreds of thousands of South Africans must be enabled to make financially sound bids to acquire individual or collective shares in SOES, and in this way, become real shareholders in South Africa Limited.

We can really liberate our Nation, question is, are we willing?