DA appeals 2nd inadequate PAIA response from Gauteng Education department

The Gauteng Education Department failed to provide the DA with all the documentation relating to the School Smart Board (ICT Tender), which was requested through a Promotion to Access of Information Act (PAIA) application.

The DA has submitted a Notice of Appeal to the department’s decision to withhold information requested. This is in accordance with section 75 of the PAIA Act.

This is the second inadequately answered PAIA from the department.

Last year, the DA was reliably informed that the department could have saved millions of rands had the ICT tender been awarded to an alternative service provider. It is alleged that the products that were delivered were not the same as those on tender specifications.

In our initial PAIA application, we requested a list of all the companies who put out to tender for the smart boards and a costing model for each. However, the department is refusing to share such information.

The department has only furnished the DA with a list of company names. Should these tenders have been awarded in an open and transparent way, it begs the question as to why the MEC is hiding this information?

It is of vital importance that whilst the MEC plans to roll out more ICT classrooms and high-level equipment to schools, that the tender process is open and transparent.

This project has raised more questions than answers. For instance, why were 88 000 tablets recalled? Not all grade 12 classrooms have smart boards and, connectivity is still a challenge as materials provided are alleged to not be the same as the ones specified in the tender notice.

The DA has asked the education committee to prioritise this project to ensure that it does not face the same fate as the R2 billion failed Gauteng online project. Should we not obtain the relevant information, for both the School Nutrition and ICT Tenders, the DA will have no other choice but to request the Office of the Public Protector to investigate.

Media Enquiries:

Khume Ramulifho MPL
DA Gauteng Shadow MEC for Education
082 398 7375

DA Debates Office Of The Premier 2015/16 Annual Report

Speech by: John Moodey MPL

“Captain Makhura denies ship Gauteng is sinking”

  • Loyalty to a once dignified and respected organisation, when it was under the able leadership of Honoured Leaders such as OR Tambo, Walter Sisulu, Nkosi Albert Luthuli, Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela, blinds the Gauteng ANC from the rot within; rot that is not only bringing ruin within its ranks, but is ruining the future of our youth and our nation as a whole.
  • The so-called open-tender system is not so open at all, leaving many small businesses without opportunities. By and large black owned businesses remain marginalised and excluded, unless of course you are politically connected.
  • The truth is that health care in this province is deteriorating. Case in point is the MEC of Health. A constantly deployed cadre that is not fit to head up this portfolio. Under her watch no less than 37 mentally ill people have died due to her negligence.
  • Civil society organisations in the province scramble looking for funding, when the MEC you’ve appointed for Social Development cannot even provide us with a list of who and where the vulnerable are.
  • In your State of the Province Address this year, you rightly acknowledged that the cost of e-tolls were too high and that this is the reason why people were not paying them. However, with residents being threatened with legal action – because they simply refuse to be subjected to an unjust and unaffordable tax, you are quiet on the matter.
  • Take heed of our constructive criticism, for your truth and the legacy you wish to leave behind, honourable Premier, should not be the story of the ANC.

The full speech can be obtained here.

 

Speech by: Jack Bloom MPL

“Makhura’s inaction is shameful”

  • As I said earlier this year in the State of the Province debate, Planet Makhura cannot escape the gravity of Planet Zuma. We know that the Honourable Premier is doing his level best to distance this province from the shenanigans of President Zuma.
  • We all know that there have been 37 confirmed deaths of psychiatric patients in a very short period after they were sent to unsuitable NGOs after the Health Department’s cancellation of the contract with Life Healthcare Esidimeni. I have called for Health MEC Qedani Mahlangu to resign or be fired, and so have many others.
  • The chairperson of the family committee Andrew Peterson has said “the department has got blood on its hand and someone should be held accountable”.
  • It is very sad that few politicians in our country do the honourable thing and resign when wrongdoing is uncovered.
  • I am sorry to say that you have missed what could have been a defining moment of your premiership where you could have showed that your provincial government really does care and really does listen.

The full speech can be obtained here

 

 

Media enquiries:

John Moodey

DA Gauteng Leader 

082 960 3743

 

Jack Bloom MPL

DA Gauteng Shadow MEC for Health

082 333 4222

[Image source]

Gauteng Education Department Cooks School Nutrition Tenders

Open Tender System

The Gauteng Department of Education has once again bungled the so-called “open tender system”, this time by awarding tenders for the school nutrition programme without following due process.

The department is now being served with a court interdict as one of the service providers has challenged the awarding of the tenders, as well as the fact that the tender was only put out to bid for 15 days.

This is in contravention of the Public Finance Management Act.

According to a reply to a DA question on the matter, Gauteng Education MEC, Panyaza Lesufi, misled the Legislature in stating that he was unaware of any allegations of corruption in awarding the school nutrition tenders.

Click here to view the reply.

Abuse Public Funds

This is an indictment on the department as it is not the first time it is being grilled for bungling the tender processes.

MEC Lesufi must take full responsibility for his department not awarding tenders in line with legislation.

The DA insists that MEC Lesufi investigate the alleged irregular awarding of these tenders and take action against officials who wilfully abuse public funds.

Tenders must be open and transparent.

The DA wants to ensure that learners are provided with quality and balanced nutrition.

 

 

Media enquiries:

Khume Ramulifho MPL

DA Gauteng Education Shadow MEC

082 398 7375

[Image source]

DA Gauteng Debates Open Tender Motion

Speech by: Adriana Randall

“More room for transparency in Gauteng’s Open Tender system”

  • Key to an open tender process is to constantly document its impact on transparency, accountability and citizen engagement.
  • The successful open tender process needs to ensure that public procurement processes are  available at all times by ensuring that technology is used effectively and that online bidding and computerised supply chain management are accessible and streamlined.
  • On 15 September 2016 the DA mayor in the City of Tshwane Metro announced the opening up of the tender process in the metro after discovering that the previous ANC government awarded multi-million rand contracts illegally to friends and family by ignoring the legal procurement processes in place.
  • It is a pity that Premier Makhura in his speech earlier told delegates that certain municipalities in the province already reneged on their election promises to open up their tender processes. I would appreciate if he could indicate who these municipalities are, as their decisions not to open up their tender processes will only drag down province’s efforts to ensure a responsible and transparent government.

The full speech can be obtained here.

 

Speech by : Ashor Sarupen

“ANC should learn from DA’s tender system”

  • The claim that Gauteng is the first to have implemented the open tender system is neither factual nor a victory. The City of Cape Town opened its bid adjudication committee to public and media scrutiny for all tenders on the first of July 2006.
  • Open tenders are not just about opening the bid adjudication committee to public scrutiny, but it should be about access to information and maximising the number of bids received. It cannot be right that the same firms get government tenders over and over.
  • The ANC in Gauteng has admitted to having paid R30 for a loaf of bread, and ANC municipalities have admitted to being charged R30 for a tungsten lightbulbs. This is because there is a massive racket of corruption happening at the request for quotation system under R30 000, where only those who have access to information put in quotes as the entire process is shrouded in secrecy.
  • I challenge the Premier and MEC Creecy to publicly challenge the Minister of Public Enterprises to make every State-owned enterprise adopt the open tender system

The full speech can be obtained here.

 

Media Enquiries:

Adriana Randall MPL

DA Gauteng Shadow MEC on Finance

060 556 4342

 

Ashor Sarupen

DA Gauteng Spokesperson on Finance

060 558 8303

[Image source]

ANC Should Learn From DA’s Tender Systems

Let me start with the ANC’s favourite quote: “tell no lies, claim no easy victories.” Often repeated in this house, but contradicted by the ANC frequently.

The claim that Gauteng is the first to have implemented the open tender system is neither factual nor a victory. The City of Cape Town, as Hon. Randall pointed out, opened its bid adjudication committee to public and media scrutiny for all tenders on the first of July 2006, for all tenders. The City of Tshwane has adopted the same system and the City of Johannesburg has announced, due to its structure, that it will be bringing the matter of opening all bid adjudication committee for a vote to full council.

Since its inception in 2006 – R15-billion worth of tenders in the City of Cape Town, every single financial year, have been awarded in an open, fair and transparent manner.

The City of Cape Town also boasts the best figures for awarding tenders to BBBEE compliant firms, since the DA does not continuously empower the same individuals over and over based on party membership and links to the ruling elite.

Despite all of this, the ANC in Gauteng has claimed it is the only government that runs open tenders through its open bid adjudication committee, despite the fact that the DA did it 10 years ago. In fact, at a recent summit, on the day the finance minister was charged by the NPA, the Premier said that the DA did not run open tenders, knowing full well that we do.

But open tenders are not just about opening the bid adjudication committee to public scrutiny, but it should be about access to information and maximising the number of bids received. It cannot be right that the same firms get tenders over and over by government.

The DA takes transparency seriously, as openness is more than just opening meetings to the public.

The ANC in Gauteng has admitted to having paid R30 for a loaf of bread, and ANC municipalities have admitted to being charged R30 for a tungsten lightbulbs. This is because there is a massive racket of corruption happening at the request for quotation system under R30 000, where only those who have access to information put in quotes as the entire process is shrouded in secrecy.

Access to tenders is equally important – all tenders and quotes above R2000 are advertised on the City of Cape Town website and companies registered in a given tender category receive a text message whenever a new tender is listed, to maximise the number of bids received. The DA’s approach is that no tender is reserved for anybody.

I challenge the ANC Government in Gauteng to follow the DA’s approach to openness, by setting up an easily accessible portal where suppliers can register at any time, specify what good or services they are able to supply and make sure that every potential supplier is made aware of requests for quotations and tenders so that a number of quotes and bids are received, and that no companies are continuously favoured in the process.

Futhermore, I challenge the Premier and MEC Creecy to publicly challenge the Minister of Public Enterprises to make every State-owned enterprise adopted the open tender system, instead of falsely claiming the DA does not run open tenders when we do. SOE’s are being fleeced for billons by a crony tender network known as the Zuma-Gupta Axis. I hereafter refer to this axis as Zupta.

In fact, state capture is being driven by the greed for tenders by the Zupta Axis. If the ANC in Gauteng is serious about ridding out country of corruption, they should order every Gauteng ANC Member of Parliament to support the DA’s motion of no confidence in the President, where there will then be enough votes to remove a corrupt president from office.

For as long as the ANC in Gauteng keeps Zuma and the Gupta’s in power, you have no leg to stand on in preaching or grandstanding about anti-corruption measures, when the leader of the ANC violated the constitution

History will judge you for allowing our national nightmare of corruption, from the highest office in the land, to continue.

 

Media enquiries:

Ashor Sarupen

DA Gauteng Spokesperson on Finance

060 558 8303

More Room For Transparency In Gauteng’s Open Tender System

There is an African proverb that reads as follows: “If you think you’re too small to make a difference you haven’t spent a night with a mosquito”.

The mosquito in this government is the extent of corruption and more especially corruption in our procurement processes. Corruption being an enemy to democracy and a stumbling block to effective service delivery and job creation.

Being stuck in damage-control mode for as long as we have been, would eventually catch up with government and force us to consider game changers, such as the opening up of the tender process in Gauteng, which MEC Creecy announced on 12 November 2014 at the launch of the more than R50m upgrade of Cedar road in Fourways .

Now game changers focus either on our greatest challenges or our best opportunities- and sometimes both come together.

With a long term vision of fostering highly skilled, innovation driven, resource efficient, connected, high opportunity for all, the City of Cape Town became the first municipality to open up their tender process in 2006, where the public were invited to attend their bid adjudication committee meetings. They became the example for many other governments to follow, yet the lack of political will and political interference prevented them to be just that.

We therefore wish to commend the Gauteng government for opening up their tender process at a time when economic growth, job creation, and levels of community trust in government is at an all-time low. We also wish to commend you on the 30 % spend of procurement on black business in the 1st six months of the current financial year.

Premier Makhura in his speech delivered at the Open Tender seminar earlier this month referred to 3 points that is crucial to curb corruption – deterrence, prevention and education.  He also said that, and I quote “In surveys, public discourse, corruption and bribery in tender processes have featured prominently as issues of great concern amongst South Africans. People demand accountability and transparency” Close quote.

As a responsible government we must empower our communities on corruption and build a trust relationship Not only is probity auditing one of the critical elements of the open tender process, but social auditing where government and society work together in a strong trust relationship, where we find strong leadership and direction, common goals, and where incompetence is never ever glorified.

Key to an open tender process is to constantly document its impact on transparency, accountability and citizen engagement.

We therefore need to ensure efficiency and transparency in procurement to promote competition among suppliers and contractors and to provide fair and equal treatment between suppliers and contractors by using a fair supplier rotation system.

The successful open tender process needs to also ensure that public procurement processes are  available at all times by ensuring that technology is used effectively and that online bidding and computerised supply chain management is accessible and streamlined; and ensure that vendors are able to be placed on vendor lists. This will speed up response times and access to government information and support as well as access to government officials and managers, and make it easier for small businesses to understand tendering processes and supply governments with the goods and services they need. These small businesses will then also be able to create jobs.

One of the most recent transparency measures in Mexico’s open tender system is the obligation for federal agencies to appoint a ‘social witness’ when the value of the contract to be awarded exceeds a certain threshold amount. Social witnesses are representatives of civil society acting as external observers in public procurement tenders. Social witnesses will participate in all stages of the procurement procedures as overseers without participating in the actual decision-making process and issues a final report compiling a testimonial of all phases of the tender.

To promote transparency, diminish corruption risks and improve the overall efficiency and reliability of public procurement, social witnesses must be honourable persons or companies who are independent from the parties involved in the tender. They are selected through a public bidding process and must meet several requirements, such as not having held public office, not having been sentenced to imprisonment, have an academic degree, work experience and professional or academic recognitions. Furthermore, to be selected, they must submit a written statement under oath that they will refrain from participating in contracts where a conflict of interest may exist. An initiative that we can definitely also benefit from.

Speaker, on the 15th September 2016 the DA mayor in the City of Tshwane Metro announced the opening up of the tender process in the metro after discovering that the previous ANC government awarded multi-million Rand contracts illegally to friends and family by ignoring the legal procurement processes in place. This led to fruitless and wasteful expenditure of public money.

It is a pity that Premier Makhura in his speech mentioned earlier told delegates that certain municipalities in the province already reneged on their election promises to open up their tender processes. I would appreciate if he could indicate who these municipalities are, as their decisions not to open up their tender processes will only drag down province’s efforts to ensure a responsible and transparent government whilst trying to build a strong trust relationship with communities.

Our provincial population is increasing annually in the face of shrinking budgets in real terms. Opening up our tender process is a responsible step, and acknowledging the challenges we face as government as far as curbing corruption, building trust relationships, delivering on services to our communities and creating jobs are concerned.

 

 

Media Enquiries:

Adriana Randall MPL

DA Gauteng Shadow MEC on Finance

060 556 4342

DA Debates 2014/15 Treasury Annual Report

Speech by: Mike Moriarty MPL

“Gauteng Treasury: A department of lost opportunities”

  • The people of Gauteng are denied the improvement of services but, even worse, the lack of progress regarding Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) denies our citizens of jobs and with it, the right to dignity.
  • Recently, we learnt that in less than 3% of cases involving forensic investigation are criminal charges actually laid against the people involved.
  • Our fellow Africans achieve far more than we do, in the same global economy, because of better government and policy certainty.

The full speech can be obtained here.

 

Speech by: Adriana Randall MPL

“Treasury needs to be more transparent with public funds”

  • The department further needs to establish what the major causes of accruals are, and how this will be addressed successfully. Urgent attention to the non-achievement of the development of a cost containment strategy must also be given seeing that it was one of the objectives not achieved.
  • It is important to have a competent and capable workforce in the department and one thing that is worrying is that highly skilled production, levels 6-8, account for the highest band making use of sick leave at 33.73 %, with highly skilled supervision – levels 9-12, the most costly band when it comes to sick leave at R1 717 000 for the period under review.
  • During a DA debate in the Gauteng Legislature over cross-departmental sharing of information regarding the details of poor performing contractors, MEC Creecy argued this would not be necessary as the transparency stemming from the open tender system would thwart this problem. However, the open tender system has thus far been less than open.

The full speech can be obtained here.

 

Media enquiries:

Mike Moriarty MPL

DA Gauteng Spokesperson on Finance

082 492 4410

 

Adriana Randall MPL

DA Gauteng Shadow MEC on Finance

060 556 4342

[Image source]